Gmail vs. Better Gmail: Change One, Break the Other
If you use the Firefox extension Better Gmail 2, recently you may have noticed some problems. Changes to Gmail's HTML and CSS layout broke some of the scripts included in this add-on. But don't worry, Better Gmail is getting better.
Don't say I didn't warn you. Three months ago, I posted a blog entry entitled "Gmail gives you options... perhaps too many". covering the complexities of using Gmail alongside various experimental features made available by Gmail Labs and the popular Firefox extension Better Gmail. Some of the scripts included in Better Gmail provide functionality redundant with (or in conflict with) features offered by Gmail Labs.
My point was that when dealing with a base service, a set of experimental features provided by a "labs" division of the company providing the service, and a third-party add-on for Firefox that aggregates independently written Greasemonkey scripts, conflict was bound to arise and users need to be careful how they configure this functionality.
Google recently made changes to Gmail's HTML and CSS layout which broke a number of Better Gmail's scripts, including my favorite, Folders4Gmail (which displays hierarchically named labels in a collapsible tree view), "Add Row Highlights", and others. I first experienced the problems when I updated Better Gmail 2 to a new version (0.7.3). The thing I noticed immediately was that the hierarchical label display was gone. But it seems that the new version was probably not the culprit: I just happened to update right after Google's layout changes.
But fear not: an entry today on Gina Trapani's blog (she's the editor of Lifehacker and the one who compiled and packaged the Better Gmail scripts), Smarterware let us know that the people behind Better Gmail are on the ball. Gina worked with Arend von Reinersdorff (who wrote several of the Better Gmail scripts) to package a "quick fix-it version" that repairs the problems associated with some of Better Gmail's functions, including Folders4Gmail. Not everything is fixed, but at least the people behind this extension are aware of the issues and are working on correcting the remaining problems. The link to download the latest version can be found on Gina's blog and on the Lifehacker web site.
- Gmail gives you options... perhaps too many (from my blog, The Voice of Rosen)
- Better Gmail 2 Fixes Now Available (from Gina Trapani's blog, Smarterware)
- Post on GetSatisfaction on the problems with Better Gmail
- Firefox add-on page for Better Gmail 2
- Lifehacker page for Better Gmail extension for Firefox


You're just saying all of this to remind me of why I use yahoo, right?
Comment by Misanthropic Scott — March 5, 2009 @ 10:53 am
Well, perhaps that's why there isn't a "Better Yahoo Mail" extension for Firefox, because Yahoo Mail is already so perfect that... yeah, right...
Seriously, several people I know are considering giving up Gmail for Yahoo because it seems to keep getting slower (with or without added extensions) and they hate the forced "conversation view" on emails. On the other hand, you have to pay Yahoo to get POP access, while with Gmail you can get both POP and IMAP, and you can forward to other accounts, for free. Not to mention the elaborate automated filtering that leads me to need Folders4Gmail to work properly.
Comment by Rich Rosen — March 5, 2009 @ 3:12 pm
Update today from Gina Trapani's blog: "All scripts have been fixed in version 0.7.3.2, which is available now!"
Comment by Rich Rosen — March 6, 2009 @ 12:59 am